網頁

2014年1月8日 星期三

法案懶人包--我們為何反對多元成家系列草案

原始網址:http://panogud1314.blogspot.tw/

法案懶人包--我們為何反對多元成家系列草


     "法案懶人包-何反對多元成家系列草案"網站聲明:          本網站由一群關心社會的熱心青年們共同製作,
          感謝所有提供修改意見的朋友們。
          所引用文章皆為網路公開文章,
          用以說明本站部分觀點。
          被引用的文章作者之立場,
          不必然等同於本站立場。
          如對網站內容有任何指正與理性之回應, 
          可寫信至 fkly5566@gmail.com。

以下為"法案懶人包--我們為何反對多元成家系列草"內容摘要,詳細內容請連結觀看

*草案簡介表格 

*『伴侶制度』與『家屬制度』無立法必要

伴侶盟不斷宣傳此草案是為了幫助弱勢的鰥寡孤獨者,但多元成家草案中所提供給他們以及他們的照護者的權益,在現行法律中已提供保障,為了博取同情而使用錯誤的宣傳,可能導致許多真正有需要的人不懂得運用已存在的法律資源來捍衛自己的權益,實在不妥。

*草案本身的問題

婚姻平權  
  法條以去性別化的方式修改:
    『夫妻』→『配偶』

    『父母』→『雙親』
    『祖父母』→『二親等直系血親尊親屬』
  上述去性別修法方式的影響:
    1. 將同性配偶也同時套用至原有法條
    2. 破壞傳統文化意象與倫理
  兒童收養制度的修改產生矛盾
  直接開放同性雙親共同收養
  單方收養與共同收養的不同

伴侶制度 
  定位模糊不清、身分混亂
  容易被濫用
  輕視兒童福祉
  該加強的是社福法
  制度規劃過於理想化

家屬制度   
  浪費社會資源

伴侶盟的動機

目的就是『毀家廢婚』
激進女權團體綁架同志與弱勢議題
性解放-刪除一切有關性的限制

    1. 通姦除罪化正在進行
    2. 保障『親人戀』、『開放式關係』、『感情濫交者』

Q & A 問與答

草案僅婚姻平權通過一讀,為何要現在反對整個多元成家草案?
1. 三案齊推,且三案皆已於2013/10/3送入立法院進行審議,
 另兩案也同時在積極尋找立委支持

2. 伴侶盟官網推動的支持連署也是三個草案一起連署
3. 伴侶盟提出的所有文宣、表格,亦都將三個草案並列
4. 伴侶盟曾表示三個一個都不會棄保。
為何有些人說多元成家草案是性解放草案?

為何要反對多元成家草案,不尊重同性戀者的基本人權?
1. 多元成家草案並非只關於同性戀者,
   三個草案所影響的都是包含所有性傾向的每一個公民。
2. 國際人權公約所保障的是能夠生兒育女的異性婚姻家庭。
3. 所以,反對包含婚姻平權在內的多元成家草案,不論就哪個層面看,
   並不違反人權公約,也無關基本人權。

為何不讓相愛的人在一起?
法律設計婚姻制度的目的是鼓勵生育,是一種生養制度,而非愛情保護制度。法律上結婚與生育乃不可分割,因此只有異性結合才能符合法律對婚姻的期待。這是基於目的考量而做的必然的篩選,並非一種歧視。
草案通過後真的可以跟很多人結婚嗎
不行的,婚姻和伴侶制度都只能跟單一對象訂定,但並不是說只能有單一伴侶就沒有小三跟劈腿。在伴侶制度中,除非雙方事前先主動另訂契約,否則的確可以跟伴侶以外的人發生性關係且無法可管。

採取行動

參加連署
分享本懶人包
邀請還不了解此議題的親朋好友們,更多地瞭解這個攸關全民的修法行動。
如果你的親朋好友在思考過後也反對多元成家草案,邀請他參加連署
遇到不同的想法、立場時,理性溝通、彼此尊重。

補充資料

迷思:『同性戀是天生的!APA早就研究證實了!』
APA(American Psychological Association ,美國心理學會)於1975年將同性戀去病化,但去病化不等同於證實為天生,且當時去病化的決議出自於『投票表決』,並非是以『研究成果』判定,在當時學術界引起許多爭議,甚至《同志伴侶諮商》一書描述APA此一決議是一種『政治操作』(第58頁)。





2014年1月5日 星期日

哈佛開放式課程《正義:一場思辨之旅》,第十二講(同性婚姻的辯論&良好生活)

哈佛開放式課程《正義:一場思辨之旅》 
第十二講(同性婚姻的辯論&良好生活)


    書目連結--
        正義: 一場思辨之旅 (JUSTICE: What’s the Right Thing to Do)
        作者: 邁可.桑德爾 (原文作者:Michael Sandel)

    YOUTUBE上的影片連結--




第1部分-同性婚姻的辯論
如果正義的原則在於其所針對權利中蘊含的道德或內在價值,那我們該怎麼面對每個人對於良善的概念都有所不同的事實?學生以激烈爭論同性婚姻是否應該合法來解決這個問題。我們可以在不討論同性戀的道德容許性或婚姻的目的之下來解決這個問題嗎?

第2部分-良好生活
Sandel 認為,政府在困難的道德問題上不能保持中立,例如同性婚姻和墮胎,並詢問為什麼我們不該以同樣的道德和宗教信念商討所有議題-包括 經濟及與公民切身相關之事。Michael Sandel教授在最後一堂課中,強而有力的提出了一個攸關公眾利益的政治新觀點。參與而不是迴避我們同胞的道德信念可能是尋求公正社會最好的方式。


本文轉引自- 真善美教學資源分享網-專題演講

2014年1月2日 星期四

我的災難式信主旅程

我的災難式信主旅程

左派女同教授 Rosaria Champagne Butterfield 信仰歷程

Come join FRC to hear about one woman's unlikely journey to faith in Christ and find ways to graciously discuss some of the toughest questions on sexuality with your friends, neighbors and family members. As a tenured lesbian professor at Syracuse University, Dr. Butterfield had no desire to become part of the heterosexist, patriarchal culture that she perceived to be the identity of Christianity. Her thinking was challenged by the letter of a local pastor who inquired about her basic presuppositions and asked her questions no one had ever asked her before. What began as an academic exercise to find fault with the Scripture and expose the darker side of Christianity ended with answers and a changed life that resonates in today's culture.

Dr. Rosaria Champagne Butterfield holds a Ph.D. in English Literature and Cultural Studies from The Ohio State University. On faculty at Syracuse University in the English Department and Women's Studies Program, with research interests and publications in feminist theory, 19th century British literature, and queer theory, she was nominated for tenure in 1998. After her conversion to Christianity in 1999, Dr. Butterfield served as adjunct faculty in English at Geneva College (Beaver Falls, Pa.), changing her academic research to Christian hermeneutics. Dr. Butterfield is married to Reverend Kent C. Butterfield, pastor of the First Reformed Presbyterian Church of Durham. The Butterfields live in Durham, N.C., with two of their four children. She loves pouring her life into her church and into homeschooling her children. She is the author of a Christian memoir, The Secret Thoughts of an Unlikely Convert: An English Professor's Journey into Christian Faith (Crown and Covenant Publications, 2012). She is working on two new books, one on Biblical sexuality and the other on Biblical hospitality. A motivational conference speaker and friend, Rosaria encourages audiences to develop Biblical fluency, trust in the inerrant and inspired word of God, and think with Biblical compassion and rigor about the cultural and political issues of our day.

Below is a description of her book:

    Rosaria, by the standards of many, was living a very good life. She had a tenured position at a large university in a field for which she cared deeply. She owned two homes with her partner, in which they provided hospitality to students and activists that were looking to make a difference in the world. There, her partner rehabilitated abandoned and abused dogs. In the community, Rosaria was involved in volunteer work. At the university, she was a respected advisor of students and her department's curriculum. And then, in her late 30s, Rosaria encountered something that turned her world upside down-the idea that Christianity, a religion that she had regarded as problematic and sometimes downright damaging, might be right about who God was, an idea that flew in the face of the people and causes that she most loved. What follows is a story of what she describes as a "train wreck" at the hand of the supernatural. These are her secret thoughts about those events, written as only a reflective English professor could. Conversion put me in a complicated and comprehensive chaos. I sometimes wonder, when I hear other Christians pray for the salvation of the "lost," if they realize that this comprehensive chaos is the desired end of such prayers. Often, people asked me to describe the "lessons" that I learned from this experience. I can't. It was too traumatic. Sometimes in crisis, we don't really learn lessons. Sometimes the result is simpler and more profound: sometimes our character is simply transformed.-Rosaria Butterfield.

影片與相關連結:http://www.frc.org/familypolicylecture/an-unlikely-convert-a-former-lesbian-professors-journey-to-faith

 
轉引自甦醒:http://wakeup-edu.blogspot.tw/2014/01/blog-post.html